As Bitcoin prices repeatedly fluctuate around $76,000 and are now approaching the $70,000 mark, the longstanding debate between gold advocate Peter Schiff and Bitcoin steadfast supporter Michael Saylor has reignited. Schiff directly criticizes Strategy’s Bitcoin holdings, which amount to approximately $54 billion, claiming they “hardly create any real value,” and mocks that its current price has nearly reached the company’s average cost basis, implying that this high-stakes gamble is on the verge of breaking even or incurring losses.
Schiff states that, based on the current price, Strategy has an unrealized loss of about 3%, and warns that risks could further increase over the next five years. He emphasizes that Bitcoin’s history is still too short to be considered a reliable long-term store of value. In his view, the company’s high concentration of assets in a single cryptocurrency inherently carries systemic risks.
Meanwhile, Saylor’s camp argues that this assessment overlooks the impact of macroeconomic conditions and liquidity cycles. Some community members point out that Strategy’s buying pace spans multiple market phases, and short-term price declines are more likely due to macro tightening and reduced risk appetite rather than a failure of Bitcoin’s fundamentals. The contraction of dollar liquidity and weakness in the US stock market have forced investors to reprice all high-volatility assets.
In terms of market performance, Strategy recently disclosed an unrealized paper loss exceeding $900 million, with MSTR’s stock price falling back to around $133, down more than 6% for the day. Bitcoin also weakened slightly during the same period, further fueling concerns about the company’s financial stability. Nevertheless, Strategy remains the largest corporate holder of Bitcoin globally, with over 710,000 coins, a scale that still holds symbolic significance within the institutional sector.
This “gold versus Bitcoin” value debate is no longer just a clash of individual opinions but a long-term contest between two asset logics. Whether short-term fluctuations will shake Strategy’s confidence remains uncertain, but as the cost basis and market price continue to narrow, risk management and capital structure issues are being pushed into sharper focus.
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to
Disclaimer.
Related Articles
DWF Labs Co-Founder: The current market is boring, but it hasn’t disappeared—builders or investors still have a lot to do.
DWF Labs co-founder Andrei Grachev said the market is currently in a “boring” phase, with many important activities quietly underway. He advised investors to stay patient and look for a better timing. He emphasized that opportunities still exist in the market—such as holding Bitcoin or participating in altcoins—and urged retail investors to keep learning and remain optimistic.
GateNews1m ago
Researchers propose a transaction scheme for quantum-resistant Bitcoin without needing a fork
Gate News message, on April 12, a researcher proposed a transaction scheme that enables quantum-resilient protection for Bitcoin without requiring a fork. At present, the quantum computing threat to Bitcoin is still at the theoretical level. Meanwhile, tech companies such as Google and Cloudflare have already begun preparing countermeasures and set a target timeline to complete the migration of quantum cryptography after 2029.
GateNews44m ago
Contract whale “sets 10 big targets first” — the short position is up $3.21 million; the BTC short opening price is $71,554.61.
Gate News message, April 12, according to on-chain analyst Ai Yi (@ai_9684xtpa) statistics, the short positions of the contract whale “first set 10 big targets” (@Jason60704294) are currently up $3.21 million. Of this, the BTC short positions are 2,567.49 BTC, with an opening price of $71,554.61, and an unrealized profit of $1.19M; the ETH short positions are 38,465.22 ETH, with an opening price of $2,248.74, and an unrealized profit of $2.03M.
GateNews55m ago
$789 Million Fresh Capital: Bitcoin ETFs See Highest Weekly Inflow Since February - U.Today
Bitcoin ETFs saw a significant resurgence with $789 million in weekly inflows, the highest since February. BlackRock led the charge, contributing 80% of this total, signaling renewed institutional interest in the market after a period of withdrawals.
UToday59m ago
Strategy Yesterday increased its holdings of 3,447 BTC through STRC, worth $250 million
Gate News message: On April 12, according to @BitcoinArchive monitoring, Strategy added 3,447 bitcoins worth $250 million yesterday (April 11) through its perpetual preferred stock product STRC. This increase is equivalent to the supply of bitcoin mined by the network over the past 8 days.
GateNews1h ago
A certain CEX’s Bitcoin whale inflows for the first time since June 2025 fell below $3 billion
CryptoQuant analyst Amr Taha noted that a major Bitcoin whale inflow to a certain CEX platform first fell below $3 billion; the market value of long-term holders recovered to $49 billion, while short-term holders fell to -$54 billion. This indicates that weak hands are distributing Bitcoin, while long-term holders are re-absorbing it.
GateNews1h ago
